India's Silent Crisis: Are We Abandoning Our Elders?

on

 

 


 https://www.yodda.care/elder-care


Last month, I visited my hometown after nearly two years. Walking through the familiar lanes, I noticed something that broke my heart. Sharma Uncle, who once headed a bustling joint family of fifteen members, now lived alone in his ancestral home. His three sons had moved to different cities, his wife had passed away, and the once-lively home echoed with silence. As we chatted over chai, his words stayed with me: "Beta, joint families are becoming museum pieces. Everyone is too busy now."

 

This isn't just Sharma Uncle's story. It's becoming increasingly common across India, a country where touching elders' feet for blessings was once a daily ritual but where now many seniors find themselves forgotten, alone, and abandoned.

 

India has always prided itself on its traditions of respecting elders. Our scriptures equate parents with gods: "Matru Devo Bhava, Pitru Devo Bhava." Our movies celebrate the sacrificial mother and the wise father. Our cultural ethos places family above individual. Yet, something is changing in modern India – a silent crisis is unfolding as more elders find themselves without support, care, or companionship in their golden years.

 

Are we, as a society, abandoning our elders? And if so, what does this say about us as a people, and where do we go from here?

 

The Growing Grey Wave: Understanding India's Elderly Population.

 

India is aging, and aging fast. According to the Ministry of Statistics and Programme Implementation, India had about 138 million elderly persons in 2021, a number projected to increase to 340 million by 2050. That's more than the entire current population of the United States!

 

The statistics paint a concerning picture:

 

  • About 15 million elderly Indians live alone, with the number increasing yearly.
  • Nearly 50% of the elderly report feeling lonely or isolated.
  • Almost 30% of seniors in urban areas live below the poverty line.
  • Just 18% of India's elderly receive any pension support.
  • Only 27% of seniors have health insurance coverage.

 

Regional differences exist too. Kerala and Tamil Nadu, with their higher literacy rates and better healthcare, provide relatively better elder care. Meanwhile, states like Bihar and Uttar Pradesh struggle with basic elder care infrastructure.

 

What makes these numbers more tragic is the contrast with our past. Just thirty years ago, over 75% of elderly Indians lived with their families in joint family systems. Today, that number has shrunk to less than 40% in urban areas.

 

Ravi Bhatnagar, a 74-year-old retired government officer in Delhi, shares: "When I was young, our home had three generations living together. Now when I visit my grandchildren, they're glued to their phones. They have time for Instagram but not for their grandfather's stories."

 

Why Are We Leaving Our Elders Behind?

 

The breakdown of traditional elder care in India isn't happening in isolation. Multiple forces are reshaping our social fabric:

 

Urban Migration and Nuclear Families.

 

Jobs and opportunities pull the young to cities, leaving elderly parents behind in villages or small towns. According to a 2020 survey by HelpAge India, 64% of elderly respondents said their children had moved away for work.

 

"My son works in Bangalore's IT sector. I live alone in Jaipur. He sends money, but what use is money when you fall ill in the middle of the night with no one to take you to hospital?" says Kamla Devi, a 68-year-old widow.

 

The emergence of nuclear families – a couple living with just their children – has become the new normal. Small urban apartments simply don't have space for grandparents. The concept of "my house" has replaced "our house."

 

Economic Pressures.

 

Let's be honest – caring for elders requires time, money, and emotional bandwidth. With rising costs of living, middle-class families struggle to manage:

 

  • Average cost of elder healthcare: ₹5,000-20,000 per month.
  • Specialized care for conditions like dementia: Up to ₹50,000 monthly.
  • Home nursing assistance: ₹15,000-30,000 monthly.

 

Many working adults find themselves in the "sandwich generation" – caring for both their children and aging parents simultaneously while trying to build careers.

 

The Communication Gap.

 

Perhaps the most painful division is cultural. Many elders struggle to relate to today's fast-paced, technology-driven lifestyle. Meanwhile, younger generations often view traditional values as outdated.

 

"My granddaughter says I don't understand her problems. Maybe she's right. But she doesn't try to understand mine either," says Baldev Singh from Amritsar, who lives in a senior citizen community after disagreements with his son's family.

 

Physical Distance = Emotional Distance.

 

When families live apart for years, emotional bonds weaken. Weekly phone calls gradually reduce to monthly, then special occasions only. What starts as physical distance often ends as emotional abandonment.

 

The Human Cost: What Happens When We Abandon Our Elders?

 

The consequence of elder abandonment isn't just statistical – it's deeply human.

 

Physical Health Consequences.

 

Elderly people living alone face serious health risks:

 

  • 64% report delayed or missed medical treatments due to lack of accompaniment.
  • 71% skip prescribed medication due to forgetfulness or confusion.
  • 41% suffer falls with no immediate help available.
  • Over 80% report skipping meals or eating nutritionally poor diets.

 

"I have diabetes and high blood pressure. Sometimes I forget which medicine to take when. My daughter-in-law used to remind me. Now I try to manage with pill boxes, but it's confusing," explains Lakshmi Amma from Kerala.

 

Mental Health Crisis.

 

The psychological impact is perhaps even more devastating:

 

  • Depression rates among abandoned elderly are 3 times higher than those living with families.
  • 67% report chronic loneliness.
  • 29% have contemplated suicide at some point.
  • Elderly suicide rates are rising, with those over 60 accounting for 10% of all suicides in India.

 

Dr. Meena Sharma, a geriatric psychiatrist in Mumbai, notes: "I see elderly patients who haven't spoken to another human being for days. Some keep the TV on just to hear voices in the house. The silence is crushing them."

 

Financial Insecurity.

 

Many elderly Indians face poverty in their final years:

 

  • Only 9% of India's workforce has formal retirement benefits.
  • 71% of rural elderly have no steady source of income.
  • Medical expenses push many seniors into debt.
  • Elder financial abuse by relatives or caretakers is increasingly common.

 

Elder Abuse: The Hidden Shame.

 

Perhaps most disturbing is the rise in elder abuse. According to the HelpAge India report, 1 in 5 elderly Indians faces some form of abuse, including:

 

  • Verbal abuse (60% of reported cases).
  • Emotional neglect (47%).
  • Financial exploitation (28%).
  • Physical abuse (24%).
  • Denial of basic needs (23%).

 

What's shocking is that in 82% of abuse cases, family members are the perpetrators.

 

What Does the Law Say?

 

Recognizing this growing crisis, India enacted the Maintenance and Welfare of Parents and Senior Citizens Act in 2007. This landmark legislation:

 

  • Makes adult children legally responsible for their parents' care.
  • Enables parents to claim maintenance up to ₹10,000 monthly.
  • Criminalizes elder abandonment with penalties including imprisonment.
  • Creates fast-track tribunals for elder cases.

 

However, implementation remains weak. Reasons include:

 

  • Many elderly are unaware of their legal rights.
  • Cultural stigma prevents elders from taking legal action against their children.
  • Tribunals are understaffed and slow.
  • Enforcement mechanisms are weak.

 

Additionally, government support schemes exist but are insufficient:

 

  • National Old Age Pension Scheme provides just ₹200-500 monthly.
  • Ayushman Bharat covers hospitalization but not regular medications or care.
  • Elder care homes run by the government accommodate less than 0.1% of those needing institutional support.

 

Compared to countries like Japan or Sweden, where comprehensive elder care is integrated into social security, India's support systems remain rudimentary.

 

The Cultural Contradiction.

 

Our abandonment of elders represents a profound cultural contradiction. All our major religious traditions emphasize elder care:

 

  • Hinduism teaches that serving parents is a pathway to spiritual merit.
  • Islam considers elder care among the highest duties after prayer.
  • Sikhism emphasizes care for the elderly as community service.
  • Christianity and Buddhism both stress honoring parents and elders.

 

Our epics like Ramayana and Mahabharata celebrate characters who sacrifice for their parents. Our traditional wisdom teaches that how we treat our elders reflects our own future.

 

Yet today's media often portrays elders as obstacles to modernity or sources of conflict. The "troublesome mother-in-law" or "stubborn old father" have become stock characters. Rarely do we see positive portrayals of intergenerational harmony.

 

Sociologist Dr. Rajesh Gill explains: "We're witnessing a society in transition, caught between traditional obligations and modern aspirations. The guilt exists, but so does the reluctance to sacrifice career or lifestyle choices."

 

Finding A Way Forward: Solutions for Modern India.

 

This crisis isn't inevitable. With thoughtful approaches, we can bridge traditional values with modern realities:

 

Reimagining Living Arrangements.

 

Some families are creating innovative solutions:

 

  • "Elder apartments" near children's homes, maintaining independence while enabling frequent visits.
  • Co-housing communities where multiple seniors live together, sharing costs and companionship.
  • Multi-generational housing complexes designed with separate units but common areas.

 

Architect Sanjay Puri, who specializes in elder-friendly housing in Mumbai, shares: "We're designing complexes where grandparents have their own space but can easily interact with grandchildren. Privacy for all generations without isolation."

 

Technology as a Bridge.

 

Technology offers promising solutions:

 

  • Video calling platforms keeping families connected despite distance.
  • Health monitoring apps allowing children to track parents' vital signs remotely.
  • Emergency response systems with one-button alerts.
  • Online communities connecting elders with similar interests.
  • Medication reminder systems.

 

Bengaluru startup ElderEase founder Sameer Malik explains: "Our app connects seniors with others in their neighborhood who share hobbies. A 65-year-old retired teacher found a walking group through us. Now she says she has more friends than ever before."

 

Community-Based Support Systems.

 

Local communities are stepping up:

 

  • "Adopt a Grandparent" programs in urban neighborhoods.
  • Religious institutions organizing regular elder meetups.
  • RWAs (Resident Welfare Associations) creating buddy systems for solo elders.
  • Volunteer groups providing companionship and assistance.

 

In Pune's Model Colony, residents organize a monthly "Seniors' Day" where elderly neighbors gather for health checkups, entertainment, and meals. "It's become something everyone looks forward to," says organizer Preeti Joshi.

 

Workplace Reforms.

 

Companies are slowly recognizing elder care needs:

 

  • Elder care leave policies (similar to maternity/paternity leave).
  • Flexible working hours for employees with elder care responsibilities.
  • Remote work options to enable care.
  • Elder care assistance programs and counseling.

 

Tata Consultancy Services recently introduced an "Elder Care Support Policy" allowing employees to work from their hometown for up to 30 days annually specifically for parent care.

 

Educational Initiatives

 

Schools can play a crucial role:

 

  • Intergenerational programs bringing students and seniors together.
  • Curriculum that emphasizes elder respect and care.
  • Life skills education that includes elder care responsibilities.
  • Parent-teacher meetings that include grandparents.

 

Delhi's Sanskriti School runs a successful "Grandparents Day" program where students record oral histories from their grandparents, creating meaningful connections while preserving family stories.

 

What Can You Do? Starting Small.

 

Change begins with individual actions:

 

  • Call your elderly relatives regularly – mark it in your calendar if needed.
  • If living away, arrange reliable help for them.
  • Include elders in family decisions, validating their experience.
  • Create family traditions that ensure regular visits.
  • Document their stories, remedies, and wisdom.
  • Teach children to respect and value the elderly.

 

Radhika Mehta, a working mother in Hyderabad, shares: "I block 30 minutes every Sunday for my children to video chat with their grandparents. Initially, they were reluctant, but now they look forward to Nani's stories and Dada's jokes."

 

Conclusion: Reclaiming Our Values in Modern Context.

 

Elder care isn't just about fulfilling duty – it's about recognizing the immense value our seniors bring. Their experiences, wisdom, patience, and perspective are irreplaceable resources in our fast-paced world.

 

By abandoning our elders, we don't just harm them – we harm ourselves. We lose connections to our roots, deprive our children of vital relationships, and create a precedent for our own old age.

 

This isn't about blindly returning to joint family systems that may not fit modern realities. It's about thoughtfully adapting our values to contemporary life – finding new ways to honor old principles.

 

As we navigate India's demographic transition, let's ask ourselves: What kind of society do we want to become? One that discards people when they're no longer economically productive? Or one that honors the full human journey from cradle to grave?

 

The answer will define not just our elders' future, but our own.

 

Resources for Elder Support.

 

  • Elderline: 14567 (National Helpline for Senior Citizens)
  • National Trust for the Welfare of Persons with Autism: www.thenationaltrust.gov.in
  • HelpAge India: www.helpageindia.org
  • Age Well Foundation: www.agewellfoundation.org
  • Dignity Foundation: www.dignityfoundation.com

Comments

Post a Comment